What does
Pip Cop do?


Go Back   Home > Forums > General forums > Member Trading Journals

» Welcome to the Pip Cop - Forex Robot Reviews and forums.
PipCop reviews MetaTrader Forex robots (EA's) in real-time and posts detailed statements every 15 minutes.
We ONLY forward test on real accounts for the most accurate robot reviews!

Be smart! Read the Review FAQ or you WILL lose money!
If you enjoy the site, please let me know by registering or donating! Thanks! -- PipCop
P.S. This message is hidden if you register!
Member Trading Journals Share your robot review statements with the community
Reply
 
LinkBack (1) Thread Tools Display Modes
Old 2010-05-27, 12:58 PM   #411 (permalink)
Site Supporter
 
rsmereka's Avatar
 
Trader for 8 - 12 years
Location: Southwestern Ontario, Canada
Posts: 1,777
My Trading Journal


Trading Live with:
Forex Hacked(Copier)
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by willhuang View Post
hehe i do like the way you think!

well yesterday, after i was literally on your journal for hours, i became an elite member of trading system forex and went ahead and got channel scrapper 1.11 using your set. hehhee. my risk is set to 12 and i set up a demo account with ibfx and well... just a few questions

1. summer and winter sets. ibfx has their headquarters in salt late city, UTAH with has a GMT of -5... what exactically do i set the summer and winter setting to? im totally confused haha..

2. how often does channel scrapper trade? i've had it running for all day yesterday and nothing is happening. it does have a smily face tho im assuming that its running. when does it do its trades?

3. the spread on ibfx for eur/gbp is 2.86. is that too high for Channel Scrapper?

4. how come only eur/gbp and not the others. can this EA run another pair too?

5. how does a us resident go about getting an uk account? what are the steps involved?

thanks in advance!
In answer to your questions:

1. It's not the timezone of the broker 's office but the time zone of their feed/server (which usually is very different). You can find out the time zone of the feed/server by looking at the MetaTrader market watch window. Right at the top of the window is the broker server time. If memory serves me right, IBFX uses GMT for their server time so your settings are:
Quote:
summergmtshift = 1
wintergmtshift = 0
2. If you are using the settings from the set file I posted here, The Channel Scalper trades in a two hour window between 20-22:00GMT. According to tradingsystemforex.com, this is the most accurate window for this EA. Keep in mind that this EA is not setup to trade often but for accuracy. It does not trade that often and since it's a scalper, the spread is very important (see my comments at the end of this post regading IBFX).

3. Like most brokers, IBFX's spread is variable. The ideal is 2.86 but you almost never get this in real trading. Also liquidity is an issue. Bottom line, under three is excellent, three is ok, greater than three will impact on your profit.

4. The Channel Scalper was designed for the EURGBP pair. Some people have claimed to trade it on other pairs but I have not investigated this.

5. First the broker has to allow US residents. Alpari UK does not. Each broker has their own requirements mostly dictated by their licensing. Usually, you have to supply a photocopy of a photo ID along with the a photocopy of the photo page of your passport and a photocopy of a utility bill.

Ok, lets talk about IBFX. Not a good broker . I had a live account with them for over a year and a half when I started trading using EA's right around when FAP Turbo hit the fan in December of 2008. Tons of traders switched when they started playing their increase the spread during the trading window game. EA's like FAP Turbo, MegaDroid and The Channel Scalper (not so much) trade a defined window every trading day (with the possible exception of Friday). IBFX is king of knocking out your EA or causing you to loose the trade by increasing the spread so much that the EA does not trade or you cannot make the total pips so you loose.

Check mt4spreads.com for the best spread . Read broker reviews at forexpeacearmy.com

Final comments...I promise.

The Channel Scalper is a great EA but it does not trade that often and (to keep it winning) you have to have a better than average EURGBP spread during an illiquid time (when the market is calm and there is not that much trading going on). For me, it is a wonderful supplementary EA. Use it with something else. I use it with MegaDroid for the one, two punch since they both do not trade that often.

I hope that this book has helped you,
Rick
__________________
MyFXBook Live Statement Mt4Analysis

Last edited by rsmereka; 2010-05-27 at 01:14 PM. Reason: Language
rsmereka is offline   Reply With Quote
   
 
Old 2010-05-27, 01:33 PM   #412 (permalink)
Rookie Pip Officer
 
Trader for 0 - 1 year
Location: usa
Posts: 23

Default

ohh. ic. thanks rick, your post has helped me a lot!

do you know where i can find the the settings for the 2 hour window? (nvm i found it)

do you have a good us broker that you think is good? where can i find more resource on this i looked all over it seems like fxdd or alpari us is okay too

Last edited by willhuang; 2010-05-27 at 01:35 PM.
willhuang is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 2010-05-27, 03:24 PM   #413 (permalink)
Site Supporter
 
rsmereka's Avatar
 
Trader for 8 - 12 years
Location: Southwestern Ontario, Canada
Posts: 1,777
My Trading Journal


Trading Live with:
Forex Hacked(Copier)
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by willhuang View Post
ohh. ic. thanks rick, your post has helped me a lot!

do you know where i can find the the settings for the 2 hour window? (nvm i found it)

do you have a good us broker that you think is good? where can i find more resource on this i looked all over it seems like fxdd or alpari us is okay too
I don't think you should go for a broker based in the US as there are also the NFA regs which are bad news. Make sure you don't consider an NFA broker (IBFX is one).

I heard nothing but bad about Alpari US. Some people like FXDD. FXPro is supposed to be ok also. I just looked at the spreads and I could not believe how low FXCBS was 0.2 on EURUSD and 0.3 on EURGBP. They are based in Cyprus and forexpeacearmy.com has some posts about problems withdrawing money.

The people here are your best resource. Ask them. Let them know what EA or what type of EA you are planning to run. Some brokers are good for scalping and some are not.

Rick
__________________
MyFXBook Live Statement Mt4Analysis
rsmereka is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 2010-05-28, 08:14 PM   #414 (permalink)
Site Supporter
 
rsmereka's Avatar
 
Trader for 8 - 12 years
Location: Southwestern Ontario, Canada
Posts: 1,777
My Trading Journal


Trading Live with:
Forex Hacked(Copier)
Default May 24-28 Week Results

It was a very good week trading my live account. Results:

Account performance, all EA's
total trades: 11
won: 11
lost: 0
net profit: $456.43
roi: 16.13%
pips: 69.0
Performance of EA MegaDroid
total trades: 4
won: 4
lost: 0
net profit: $290.04
roi: 10.06%
pips: 41.0
Performance of EA The Channel Scalper
total trades: 7
won: 7
lost: 0
net profit: $166.39
roi: 6.07%
pips: 28.0

It was a losing week trading my demo account. Caliber FX Pro (GBPUSD and USDJPY) both lost big. Results:

Account performance, all EA's
total trades: 30
won: 10
lost: 18
net profit: $-1585.59
roi: -7.31%
pips: -83.4
Performance of EA Heikenizer
total trades: 4
won: 1
lost: 1
net profit: $22.73
roi: 0.18%
pips: 125.9
Performance of EA Caliber FX Pro (EURUSD)
total trades: 17
won: 6
lost: 11
net profit: $241.65
roi: 1.79%
pips: 20.1
Performance of EA Caliber FX Pro (GBPUSD)
total trades: 5
won: 1
lost: 4
net profit: $-1182.12
roi: -6.3%
pips: -160.9
Performance of EA Caliber FX Pro (USDJPY)
total trades: 4
won: 2
lost: 2
net profit: $-667.85
roi: -2.98%
pips: -68.5
Performance of EA Caliber FX Pro (all pairs)
total trades: 26
won: 9
lost: 17
net profit: $-1608.32
roi: -7.49%
pips: -209.3

Rick
__________________
MyFXBook Live Statement Mt4Analysis
rsmereka is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 2010-05-29, 03:40 PM   #415 (permalink)
Rookie Pip Officer
 
Trader for 0 - 1 year
Location: usa
Posts: 23

Default

hey rick, for the past few days i've been playing with channel scalper and using the test center of the mt4.

the results really varies for the hours. pairs etc...

i was just wondering, do u know of any resources that can tell me the best pair trading hours with the least amount of spread ?

oh and what kind of trading strat does megadroid use? and what pairs are u running it on?

Last edited by willhuang; 2010-05-29 at 03:41 PM.
willhuang is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 2010-05-30, 11:48 AM   #416 (permalink)
Site Supporter
 
rsmereka's Avatar
 
Trader for 8 - 12 years
Location: Southwestern Ontario, Canada
Posts: 1,777
My Trading Journal


Trading Live with:
Forex Hacked(Copier)
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by willhuang View Post
hey rick, for the past few days i've been playing with channel scalper and using the test center of the mt4.

the results really varies for the hours. pairs etc...

i was just wondering, do u know of any resources that can tell me the best pair trading hours with the least amount of spread ?

oh and what kind of trading strat does megadroid use? and what pairs are u running it on?
The resources you seek are in the TCS thread on tradingsystemforex. They have run the EA with many different pairs and have adjusted the settings. The set file I am using was originally the best one I saw after reading the entire thread.

MegaDroid is also a scalper which trades only EURUSD (straight version, not the pro version) in the quiet time after London close 22-00GMT. It aims for either 5 pips or 10 pips depending.

Rick
__________________
MyFXBook Live Statement Mt4Analysis
rsmereka is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 2010-05-30, 12:40 PM   #417 (permalink)
Rookie Pip Officer
 
Trader for 0 - 1 year
Location: usa
Posts: 23

Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by rsmereka View Post
The resources you seek are in the TCS thread on tradingsystemforex. They have run the EA with many different pairs and have adjusted the settings. The set file I am using was originally the best one I saw after reading the entire thread.

MegaDroid is also a scalper which trades only EURUSD (straight version, not the pro version) in the quiet time after London close 22-00GMT. It aims for either 5 pips or 10 pips depending.

Rick
ohh ic ok i'll go through it again. i've been reading up many different EA and found cs to be quite good for the eugbp pair
willhuang is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 2010-06-01, 11:52 AM   #418 (permalink)
Site Supporter
 
rsmereka's Avatar
 
Trader for 8 - 12 years
Location: Southwestern Ontario, Canada
Posts: 1,777
My Trading Journal


Trading Live with:
Forex Hacked(Copier)
Default May Month Results

It was a very good month trading my live account even though I suffered a large loss with Forex Maximizer. Both MegaDroid and The Channel Scalper saved my bacon. Results:

Account performance, all EA's
total trades: 59
won: 51
lost: 8
net profit: $958.32
roi: 38.8%
pips: -261.2
Performance of EA MegaDroid
total trades: 17
won: 17
lost: 0
net profit: $723.72
roi: 26.79%
pips: 167.9
Performance of EA The Channel Scalper
total trades: 35
won: 32
lost: 3
net profit: $864.46
roi: 33.98%
pips: 158.8
Performance of EA Forex Maximizer (GBPUSD)
total trades: 3
won: 1
lost: 2
net profit: $-125.77
roi: -4.45%
pips: -125.5
Performance of EA Forex Maximizer Advanced (GBPJPY)
total trades: 4
won: 1
lost: 3
net profit: $-504.09
roi: -17.52%
pips: -462.4
Performance of EA Forex Maximizer (both pairs)
total trades: 7
won: 2
lost: 5
net profit: $-629.86
roi: -21.97%
pips: -587.9

There was a small gain in my demo account this month. Caliber FX Pro has huge swings in equity (over 20%) and right now, it's in a low period. Results:

Account performance, all EA's
total trades: 135
won: 61
lost: 65
net profit: $231.47
roi: 7.21%
pips: 1895.6
Performance of EA Heikenizer
total trades: 25
won: 12
lost: 4
net profit: $822.19
roi: 4.54%
pips: 1796.7
Performance of EA Caliber FX Pro (EURUSD)
total trades: 81
won: 34
lost: 47
net profit: $894.16
roi: 7.94
pips: 87.1
Performance of EA Caliber FX Pro (GBPUSD)
total trades: 17
won: 8
lost: 9
net profit: $-62.67
roi: 1.76%
pips: 167.7
Performance of EA Caliber FX Pro (USDJPY)
total trades: 10
won: 6
lost: 4
net profit: $-1061.21
roi: -5.02%
pips: -119.8
Performance of EA Caliber FX Pro (all pairs)
total trades: 108
won: 48
lost: 60
net profit: $-229.72
roi: 4.68
pips: 135.0

Rick
__________________
MyFXBook Live Statement Mt4Analysis
rsmereka is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 2010-06-04, 07:55 PM   #419 (permalink)
Site Supporter
 
rsmereka's Avatar
 
Trader for 8 - 12 years
Location: Southwestern Ontario, Canada
Posts: 1,777
My Trading Journal


Trading Live with:
Forex Hacked(Copier)
Default May 31-Jun 4 Week Results

It was a very good week trading my live account. Results:

Account performance, all EA's
total trades: 8
won: 8
lost: 0
net profit: $348.64
roi: 10.78%
pips: 43.7
Performance of EA MegaDroid
total trades: 2
won: 2
lost: 0
net profit: $183.09
roi: 5.69%
pips: 19.7
Performance of EA The Channel Scalper
total trades: 6
won: 6
lost: 0
net profit: $165.55
roi: 5.09%
pips: 24.0

It was a major losing week trading my demo account. Results:

Account performance, all EA's
total trades: 25
won: 11
lost: 13
net profit: $-2896.97
roi: -18.07%
pips: 168.4
Performance of EA Heikenizer
total trades: 6
won: 2
lost: 3
net profit: $-1727.1
roi: -10.8%
pips: 28.7
Performance of EA Caliber FX Pro (EURUSD)
total trades: 14
won: 5
lost: 9
net profit: $-2079.07
roi: -12.93%
pips: -127.4
Performance of EA Caliber FX Pro (GBPUSD)
total trades: 4
won: 3
lost: 1
net profit: $844.37
roi: 5.26%
pips: 257.1
Performance of EA Caliber FX Pro (USDJPY)
total trades: 1
won: 1
lost: 0
net profit: $64.83
roi: 0.4%
pips: 10.0
Performance of EA Caliber FX Pro (all pairs)
total trades: 19
won: 9
lost: 10
net profit: $-1169.87
roi: -7.27%
pips: 139.7

Rick
__________________
MyFXBook Live Statement Mt4Analysis
rsmereka is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 2010-06-08, 08:55 AM   #420 (permalink)
Site Supporter
 
rsmereka's Avatar
 
Trader for 8 - 12 years
Location: Southwestern Ontario, Canada
Posts: 1,777
My Trading Journal


Trading Live with:
Forex Hacked(Copier)
Default Account Changes

I made the following account changes:

Live
-increase the risk of MegaDroid to 0.40 (40%)

Demo
-removed Heikenizer
-removed Calibre FX Pro
-added Titan

Both Heikenizer and Calibre FX Pro were subject to wide swings of equity (20-30%) and are not the kind of EA that I would put on my live account.

Titan is a non-commercial proprietary EA that belongs to a friend.

Rick
__________________
MyFXBook Live Statement Mt4Analysis
rsmereka is offline   Reply With Quote
Reply

Bookmarks

Thread Tools
Display Modes


LinkBacks (?)
LinkBack to this Thread: http://www.PipCop.com/forums/member-trading-journals/171-rsmereka-trading-journal.html
Posted By For Type Date
Pip Cop - Forex Robot Reviews This thread Refback 2009-08-28 03:56 PM



All times are GMT -5. The time now is 09:18 AM.

Powered by vBulletin ®
Site content and design Copyright © 2010 PipCop, LLC.
Site designed, hosted, and maintained by One Web Ave
Template by vBSkinworks.
Content Relevant URLs by vBSEO 3.3.2